Good vs Bad Welds: Undercut, Porosity and Other Defects

A good weld has a uniform bead width and ripple, fuses fully into both pieces, blends smoothly at the edges and has no cracks, holes or gaps. A bad weld shows defects such as undercut (a groove at the edge), porosity (pinholes), lack of fusion, overlap, spatter, slag inclusions or cracks, usually from the wrong current, speed, angle, shielding gas or dirty metal.

Good weld vs bad weld at a glance

FeatureGood weldBad weld
Bead widthEven along the jointWavy, narrow or wide in spots
RipplesEvenly spacedIrregular, lumpy
EdgesBlend smoothly into the metalGroove (undercut) or overlap
SurfaceSolid, no holesPinholes, craters or cracks
FusionJoins both pieces fullyEdges not melted together
SpatterLittleA lot

Common weld defects, causes and fixes

DefectWhat it looks likeCommon causesFix
UndercutA groove along the toe of the weldCurrent too high, travel too fast, arc too long, wrong angleLower current, slow down, shorten the arc, pause at the edges
PorosityPinholes or surface bubblesDirty or rusty metal, damp rods, lost gas, windClean to bright metal, dry the rods, check gas and shield from wind
Lack of fusionWeld sits on top without joiningLow current, fast travel, dirty jointRaise current, slow down, aim the arc at the joint
Lack of penetrationThe root of the joint is not meltedLow current, tight gap, wrong angleIncrease current or gap, use a proper bevel
Overlap (cold lap)Weld metal rolls over the edge without joiningTravel too slow, current too lowRaise current, speed up
SpatterDroplets around the weldArc too long, wrong gas, high wire speedShorten the arc, adjust settings
Slag inclusionSlag trapped in the weldSlag not cleaned between passesChip and brush after each pass
CracksLines in or beside the weldFast cooling, hydrogen, high carbon steel, restraintPreheat, use dry low-hydrogen rods, grind out and re-weld
Burn-throughHoles in thin metalCurrent too high, slow travelLower current, speed up, use a backing

Undercut in more detail

Undercut weakens the plate right at the toe of the weld, where stresses concentrate. It is common when the current or the arc length is too great. Reduce current, hold a shorter arc, keep the electrode angle steady and pause slightly at each edge so the weld metal fills the groove. A shallow undercut can be filled with a light extra pass, and deep undercut may need grinding and repair.

Porosity in more detail

Porosity comes from gas bubbles that freeze in the weld. Rust, oil and paint release gas, damp rods release hydrogen and a draft blows away shielding gas. Clean the joint to bright metal, keep rods dry (see 7018 welding rod storage), and weld in a draft-free area when using shielding gas. For wire-feed welders, check that the gas flows and that nothing blocks the nozzle; see what is MIG welding and flux core vs MIG.

Checking your own welds

  1. Look at the weld with good light after cleaning off slag.
  2. Check for even width, smooth edges and no holes or cracks.
  3. Practice on scrap, then break or bend a test piece to see whether the weld has joined the metal.
  4. Adjust one setting at a time.

Welds on load-bearing parts, pressure vessels and anything where failure causes injury need a qualified inspector and the right code. A home welder’s visual check is not enough for those. For stick setup, see stick welders.

Frequently asked questions

What is undercut in welding?

A groove melted into the base metal along the edge of the weld that the weld metal did not fill. It thins the plate and creates a stress point.

What causes porosity in a weld?

Gas trapped in the weld metal. Common causes are rust, oil or paint on the metal, damp electrodes, lost shielding gas from wind or a leak, and an arc held too long.

How can I tell if a weld is strong?

A uniform bead with full fusion and no visible defects is a good sign, but strength is not proven by looks alone. Structural welds must be inspected or tested to the code that applies.

Can I fix a bad weld?

Many defects can be ground out and re-welded. Cracks must be removed completely first. For structural work, follow the repair procedure the code requires.

Report a mistake on this page