Flux Core vs MIG Welding: Which Wire and Setup to Use

Flux-core welding uses a hollow wire filled with flux, and the self-shielded kind needs no gas, so it works outdoors and on dirtier or thicker steel. MIG uses a solid wire with shielding gas for cleaner, less spattery welds, and it is easier on thin sheet. Many home wire-feed welders can run both, so the choice often comes down to the wire and the polarity you set.

Flux core vs MIG at a glance

Flux core (self-shielded)MIG (solid wire and gas)
ShieldingFlux in the wireGas from a bottle
Gas bottle neededNoYes (often argon and CO2)
PolarityElectrode negative (DCEN)Electrode positive (DCEP)
Outdoors and windWorks wellGas blows away in wind
Spatter and smokeMoreLess
Slag to chip offYesNo
Thin sheetHarderEasier
Rust and dirtTolerates moreNeeds clean metal
Typical useFarm repair, thicker steel, outdoor workAuto body, fabrication, clean joints

How flux-core welding works

Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) feeds a continuous tubular wire. The flux in the core burns to make a shielding gas and a layer of slag that covers the weld as it cools. Chip the slag off when it is cold. There are two kinds:

  • Self-shielded flux core makes its own gas and needs no bottle.
  • Gas-shielded flux core uses the flux and an external gas, usually CO2 or an argon and CO2 mix, and gives a cleaner weld.

How MIG welding works

MIG (GMAW) feeds a solid wire while an inert or mixed gas shields the pool. There is no slag, the weld looks clean and flat, and spatter is low, but the gas must reach the weld. A fan or even a breeze can blow it away. For the process itself, see what is MIG welding.

Which to choose

  1. Welding thin sheet, auto body or clean joints indoors: MIG with solid wire and gas.
  2. Welding outdoors, in a breeze, or on rusty or painted steel you cannot grind clean: self-shielded flux core.
  3. Welding thicker steel with a smaller machine: flux core runs hotter than solid wire at the same settings, so it often does better on a 120 V machine.
  4. Welding stainless or aluminum: MIG with the right wire and gas; self-shielded flux core is for carbon steel, with special wires for some stainless. See how to weld stainless steel.

Setting up for flux core

  1. Fit flux-core wire (often 0.030 or 0.035 in on home machines) and the matching knurled drive roller.
  2. Switch the polarity to electrode negative if the wire is self-shielded. The machine’s manual shows how to swap the leads.
  3. Set voltage and wire speed from the chart inside the machine.
  4. Drag the gun, rather than pushing it, so the slag trails behind the pool.
  5. Clean the slag after each pass and brush the weld.

Safety

Flux-core welding makes more smoke and fumes, so weld in a ventilated space or outdoors. Wear a helmet with the right shade, gloves, flame-resistant clothing and eye protection, and follow welding safety tips.

Frequently asked questions

Is flux core easier than MIG?

Flux core is easier to set up because it needs no gas bottle, and it tolerates wind and some rust. MIG gives cleaner, flatter welds and is easier on thin metal.

Does flux-core wire need gas?

Self-shielded flux-core wire does not. Gas-shielded flux-core wire needs shielding gas, usually CO2 or an argon and CO2 mix.

What polarity does flux core use?

Self-shielded flux-core wire usually runs on electrode negative (DCEN). Solid MIG wire with gas runs on electrode positive (DCEP). Check the wire maker's label.

Can I weld thin sheet with flux core?

It is possible, but difficult. Flux-core welds run hotter and spatter more, so solid-wire MIG is the better choice for thin sheet and auto body.

Report a mistake on this page