Can I Use a Torque Wrench as a Breaker Bar?

You shouldn’t use a torque wrench as a breaker bar. A stuck or rusted bolt can need far more force to break loose than it was tightened to, and that force goes straight through the wrench’s measuring mechanism. On a click-type wrench it can bend or overload the internal spring and knock the calibration out, so every bolt you tighten afterward is wrong. Break the bolt loose with a breaker bar, spin it out with a ratchet, and keep the torque wrench for the final tightening.

Torque wrench vs breaker bar

Torque wrenchBreaker bar
JobTightens a fastener to a set torqueLoosens tight or seized fasteners
InsideA spring and click mechanism, a beam, or a strain gaugeSolid steel bar, no mechanism
Load limitThe top of its scaleFar beyond a torque wrench of the same length
RatchetUsually ratchetingUsually a flexible head, no ratchet
What overloading doesShifts the calibration, can break the mechanismVery little

Why loosening is hard on a torque wrench

  • Breakaway torque is higher than tightening torque. Rust, thread locker and heat cycles mean a bolt tightened to 100 ft-lb can take much more to start turning. A wrench that tops out at 150 ft-lb can easily be pushed past its limit.
  • Shock loads. When a stuck bolt suddenly gives, the wrench takes a jolt that the click mechanism isn’t designed for.
  • Many click wrenches only measure clockwise. Some can click counterclockwise for left-hand threads, but turning them hard counterclockwise is still outside what they’re meant for. The manual says which directions are calibrated.

A beam-type torque wrench has no spring, so it’s more forgiving, but the same rule applies: don’t pull past the end of its scale.

How to loosen a tight bolt the right way

  1. Use a six-point socket or wrench that fits snugly, so it grips the flats instead of rounding the corners. A ratcheting wrench is handy for spinning the nut off once it’s loose.
  2. Apply penetrating oil to rusted threads and give it time to soak in.
  3. Use a breaker bar, pulling smoothly. A longer bar gives more leverage; don’t add a pipe extension to a ratchet or torque wrench.
  4. Check the thread direction. Some fasteners are left-hand threaded and loosen clockwise; left-hand vs right-hand drill bits covers removing broken ones.
  5. For badly seized bolts, heat (on metal parts away from fuel and plastics) or an impact wrench may be needed.

Looking after a torque wrench

  • Store a click wrench at its lowest setting, not under spring tension, and not below the bottom of the scale.
  • Don’t drop it. A drop can shift the calibration.
  • Have it checked about once a year or every 5,000 uses, whichever comes first, and after any drop or overload. Types of torque wrenches covers accuracy and calibration in more detail.
  • Use it only for tightening, with the right socket and no extensions on the handle.

If you used a torque wrench to loosen something before and the readings now seem off, have it calibrated before relying on it again.

Related guides

Report a mistake on this page