Self-Drilling vs Self-Tapping Screws: Which Do You Need?

A self-drilling screw has a fluted tip shaped like a small drill bit, so it drills its own hole and cuts its threads in one step, with no pilot hole. A self-tapping screw cuts or forms its own threads as you drive it, but most types need a pilot hole drilled first. Every self-drilling screw is self-tapping; not every self-tapping screw is self-drilling.

The choice comes down to the material and its thickness: self-drilling screws for sheet steel, steel studs and metal roofing; self-tapping screws for plastics, aluminum, and steel too thick for a drill point.

What is the difference between self-drilling and self-tapping screws?

The difference is the tip. Look at the point before you buy:

Self-drilling screwSelf-tapping screw
TipFluted drill point (like a twist drill)Sharp point, blunt point, or a cutting slot
Pilot holeNot neededNeeded for most types and materials
Steps1 (drill + tap together)2 (drill the pilot, then drive)
Main useSheet steel, steel studs, metal roofing, wood to steelPlastic, aluminum, thicker steel, pre-drilled holes
Common namesTek screws, drill-point screwsSheet metal screws, thread-forming and thread-cutting screws
Speed on the jobFastest: one tool, one stepSlower: pilot hole first

Because a self-drilling screw makes its own hole, the hole always matches the thread. That’s the main advantage on a roof or in steel framing: no bit changes and no mismatched pilot holes.

How does a self-drilling screw work?

The drill point cuts a hole slightly smaller than the thread. As the point breaks through, the threads behind it reach the hole and tap it. The unthreaded length of the drill point (the flute) must be longer than the material is thick. If the threads touch the metal before the point has drilled all the way through, the screw tries to tap and drill at the same time, binds, and snaps or strips.

That’s why self-drilling screws come with a point number. A bigger number means a longer, stronger drill point for thicker steel. Typical ranges are:

PointTypical steel thickness it drills
#2Light sheet metal, about 0.035 to 0.100 in
#3Light to medium steel, about 0.036 to 0.140 in
#4Medium steel, about 0.175 to 0.250 in
#5Heavy steel, about 0.250 to 0.500 in

Ranges differ between makers, so check the chart on the box. When two layers are joined, add their thicknesses together.

When do you need a self-tapping screw instead?

Use a self-tapping screw when a drill point is the wrong tool:

  • Plastics and soft materials. Thread-forming self-tapping screws push the material aside instead of cutting it, so plastic holds the thread without cracking.
  • Aluminum and thin brass. A pilot hole plus a thread-cutting screw gives cleaner threads than a drill point that may clog.
  • Steel thicker than a #5 point can drill. Drill a pilot hole and drive a thread-cutting screw.
  • Existing holes. When you’re replacing a screw in a hole that’s already there, a self-tapping screw reuses it.

Pilot hole size matters with self-tapping screws: too small and the screw snaps, too big and it strips. For the most common size, see our chart for the drill bit size for a #10 screw. It covers pilot and clearance holes for wood and metal.

Which screw for which job?

JobUseWhy
Metal roofing and sidingSelf-drilling with an EPDM sealing washerDrills and seals in one step; the washer keeps water out
Steel studs and trackSelf-drilling, #2 or #3 pointLight-gauge steel; fast with a screw gun
Wood or plywood to steelWinged self-drillingWings ream the wood so it doesn’t lift off the steel, then break off
Brackets on heavy steelSelf-drilling #4 or #5, or pilot + self-tappingThick steel needs a long point or a pilot hole
Plastic parts and enclosuresThread-forming self-tappingForms threads without cracking the plastic
Aluminum trimPilot hole + self-tappingCleaner threads, no clogged point

How to drive self-drilling screws without snapping them

  1. Use a drill/driver or screw gun with a clutch. Set the clutch so it slips once the head seats; if you’re unsure what the numbers mean, see what the numbers on a drill mean. An impact driver works on small screws but makes over-tightening and stripped threads more likely.
  2. Run at medium speed, not full speed. Too fast burns the drill point before it’s through. Many makers list roughly 1,800 to 2,500 rpm for #8 to #12 screws in steel; slower for larger screws and thicker metal.
  3. Push firmly and straight. Steady pressure keeps the point cutting. Stop as soon as the point breaks through and the threads pull the screw in.
  4. Don’t over-drive washered screws. The rubber washer should be snug and slightly bulged, not squashed flat.

Material and coating

  • Zinc-plated carbon steel: indoor and dry use.
  • Ceramic or polymer coated: outdoor and treated lumber.
  • 410 stainless: hardened stainless that can drill steel itself; good corrosion resistance.
  • 300-series (304/316) stainless: best corrosion resistance, but too soft to drill steel on its own. Self-drilling versions use a hardened carbon-steel tip (bi-metal screws).

When you’re drilling a pilot hole in stainless steel for a self-tapping screw, the bit matters more than the screw: see the best drill bits for stainless steel.

Self-drilling vs self-tapping: quick rule

If you’re fastening into steel up to about 1/2 in and don’t want to drill first, use a self-drilling screw with the right point number. If you’re fastening into plastic, aluminum, or a hole that already exists, use a self-tapping screw with the right pilot hole.

Frequently asked questions

Do self-drilling screws need a pilot hole?

No. The drill point makes the hole. You only need a pilot hole when the metal is thicker than the screw's drill point can cut, and in that case use a screw with a bigger point number instead.

Can you use self-drilling screws in wood?

Yes, but they're made for metal. For wood fastened to steel, use winged self-drilling screws: the wings ream a clearance hole in the wood, then snap off when they reach the steel.

Are Tek screws self-drilling or self-tapping?

Tek is a brand name that became the common name for self-drilling screws. A Tek screw drills and taps in one step, so it's both.

Report a mistake on this page